The CNVC Office is closed Thursday, November 22, 2018, and Friday, November 23, 2018, for the US Thanksgiving Day holiday.

Pain Lasers and Love Lasers

by Bob Wentworth

In graduate school, I became an expert on lasers, devices that produce intense beams of exceptionally pure light. So, it's only natural that I sometimes use lasers as metaphors for how our minds work. I find the metaphor useful in understanding why some of us suffer as much as we do, and in charting a course towards more delightful ways of being.

To make a laser, you take a transparent substance that has been engineered to amplify light, and you put mirrors around it. A material that can amplify light will also spontaneously produce small amounts of light. When a tiny bit of light appears, if it is traveling in the right direction it will encounter the mirrors. Bouncing back and forth between the mirrors, with every pass through the amplifying material, it grows more and more intense. Typically one of the mirrors is designed to be only partly reflective, so some of the light will leak out, so that it can be used to do something useful. Some lasers produce light so intense that the light that leaks out can cut steel, or travel to the moon and back.

I have noticed that my mind works somewhat similarly. I spontaneously experience something slightly unpleasant or painful. I notice that discomfort or pain, and, if it is of a certain type (headed towards my mental mirrors), I'll have a reaction to it. Maybe it reminds me of some old unhealed pain, and that old pain starts flooding into my body-mind. Or maybe I think, "Crap! I don't want to feel pain -- why do I always have to put up with these unpleasant sensations!?" and as I think that, the pain and suffering increase, become more intense. In either case, the initial small unpleasantness has been amplified, and a more intense unpleasantness is now present. Typically, I react to this more intense experience in a way that further amplifies it, until it reaches an intensity of suffering that, although I'm all too used to it, is hard to endure.

This is what it's like to be a pain laser (or a more accurately, a suffering laser). It doesn't take much in the way of external circumstances to produce suffering--I'm so good at amplifying whatever whiffs of suffering naturally occur that I've spent much of my life with a constant background of signficant inner suffering that I've felt at a loss to do much about.

I've shifted this pattern over the years so that it's less pronounced, but it's still often present. So, when a while ago I was thinking about acting to make my life better, it occurred to me that changing my external circumstances was never going to create the experience of life I wanted until I shifted this inner pattern. The key to whether or not this pattern will be active is this: When pain and suffering occur, will I react to it in a way that increases (amplifies) my suffering, or will I react in a way that soothes (decreases) my suffering? Because of the "mirror" effect, where I react to my reactions to my reactions to my reactions (and so on), changing my pattern modestly--from slightly amplifying to slightly soothing--if applied at every level of reaction, can have a dramatic effect in terms of my ultimate experience.

Usually the most pernicious reactions are the ones I notice the least, because I'm identified with them--they just seem like "me." So, I might have a lot of muscular tension, and some anxiety, present in my body. As I focus my attention on that tension and anxiety, I may unconsciously wrinkle my nose as if I'm smelling a foul odor, and experience a sense of disapproval towards that tension and anxiety, quietly thinking "It shouldn't be like that!" That disapproval acts like an amplifier for my suffering, cementing the tension and anxiety in place, and making them more intense. It's important for me to notice that disapproval. But simply noticing isn't enough. If I disapprove of that disapproval, things just get worse. But, if I can simply notice it, and trust that it's an expression of a beautiful longing for my well-being (this is where NVC comes in, with its insight that everything is simply an attempt to meet a beautiful human need), then the power of that disproval begins to dissipate, and some of the tension and anxiety start to ease.

I can do more, by starting to change the way I think about what is happening inside me. I can trust that everything that happens is out of an intention of some part of me to care for me, to express its love for me. I can think that any signs of woundedness are not things to chastised, but things to be nurtured.

Even as I work on eliminating the amplification of suffering, I can also turn to looking to ways I might start to amplify more life-serving experiences. Do I sense, anywhere in my body, a bit of well-being? Or even a bit of pleasure, or joy, appreciation, or love? Am I willing to let my attention rest there? In the absence of any negative reactions to what I'm witnessing, my attention can serve like a gentle breath blowing on an ember, inviting it to glow more brightly. If I do this often enough, those life affirming emotions and inner experiences can start to habitually intensify. Maybe one day soon I'll be a "love laser," taking the glimmers of love that naturally arise and getting in the habit of amplying those until I am saturated with love, and my "love light" shines intensely out into the world. Wouldn't that be something?

And wouldn't it really be something if we could all shut down our "pain lasers" and become "love lasers"? Would you like that? Is there any part of you that believes it might be possible? What's a small step you could take to get just a bit closer to being in the world in that way?

(If this essay has contributed to you in some way, I'd enjoy hearing about it. May your love laser shine brightly! Bob. Sept. 30, 2012)

Bob Wentworth is a CNVC Certified Trainer and a member of the board of directors of The Center of Nonviolent Communication. He is an active member of Capital NVC, and a co-founder of Family HEART Camp, an NVC immersion experience for parents and children. Bob has a Ph.D. in Applied Physics from Stanford University.

Your rating: None Average: 4.8 (9 votes)


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Thanks for the Handy Metaphor!

I love this because I so relate to the experience of unwittingly and even subtlely amplifying unpleasant feelings and thoughts; because I can use the same skill to enhance my pleasant feelings!; because it empowers me to have a measure of control over where I spend my attentional energy, and reminds me of my goal to cultivate inner peace, safety and self-soothing empathy in the moment! I also learned how lasers get their intensity . . . and agree that a love laser is a handy tool to have in mind!

Love Lasers

Great article and analogy. I am new to NVC and lasers, but understanding the magnifying way lasers make something powerfull out of something small, and applying that analogy to how I choose to respond or default by reacting to triggers is very insightful. I look forward to more practice.


I enjoyed the analogy. It spoke to me about focusing on the abilities of our humanness instead of focusing on our suffering. It's an inner journey of peace. As we change inside, we see the external shifts. I believe this is how to change the world. One heart at a time. Thank you for your kind words.
Colleen Johanna

choosing what to amplify

What a wonderful and empowering metaphor ! It immediately raises our awareness of what we habitually tend to do (over attend to some difficulty and pondering bon that matter, amplify the pain an anxiety) ... and show we know what to do to shift form this pattern of giving ourselves pain, we only need to give our attention and energy to amplifying the kindnesses we receive, and shine gratitude and tenderness back.. Thank you! : )

Singing and dancing and drawing in hope Yasmin

Simply to understand

Hi Bob, Thanks for sharing this article, Great analogy, simple to understand.


Thank you, Bob!我很开心也很乐意成为爱的激光,来照亮这个世界,而且我正朝着它而努力。说起来,它的确不容易,当我们痛苦时,也是我们心灵最脆弱的时候,我们很容易放大我们的痛苦,并去阻止它的表达,然而痛苦也是向我们表达对生命的爱的一种方式,当我们仔细倾听它的声音,接纳它时,痛苦就转化为实现生命美好的积极行动了,这一切是那么的不可思议,妙不可言。非常谢谢你用激光的例子生动地解释如何去面对我们的痛苦,让它变得容易理解。

I felt grateful to read this topic!

I think this was the exact article I needed to read today. Occasionally, I have pain in my body. Prior to reading this article, I'd regard the pain as my body's attempt at punishing me. Now that I've read this article, I'm convinced it's my loving body saying, "Oge, I really want to take care of your foot but I can't. Would you be willing to help me out by taking some painkillers?" This new way of thinking about my body is definitely nonviolent, as opposed to my previous way of thinking that was based on punishment. Such beliefs make one think the body is more powerful than the mind and one is held in the grips of the human body. With this article, I now view my body as my partner. Not as a slavedriver.

The Center for Nonviolent Communication
9301 Indian School Rd NE Suite 204
Albuquerque, NM 87112-2861 USA
Tel: +1.505.244.4041 | Fax: +1.505.247.0414 | US Only: 800 255 7696

NEW fundraising opportunity for US residents.